New Law in New York to Measure Fairness of Minorities Representation in Civil Jury Pools
When I started trying cases about 25 years ago New York County (Manhattan) was considered to be a plaintiff-friendly venue due to juries' proclivity to render favorable verdicts. Today the plaintiffs' bar views Manhattan juries quite differently. Litigators often attribute this to the elimination of jury service exemptions, which meant that many of the more conservative leaning professionals who reside in Manhattan who routinely avoided jury service could no longer do so. But other lawyers saw a different reason - that jury pools were skewed so that minorities were underrepresented in comparison to their proportion of the population. A study was done in 2006, and last week Governor David A. Paterson signed into law the Jury Pool Fair Representation Act. The Jury Pool Fair Representation Act requires the collection of demographic data for jurors who present for service and for the submission of such data in an annual report to the governor, speaker of the assembly