Unwanted Prolongation of Life Held Not Actionable Without Separate Injury By SEO Admin on March 24, 2009

The plaintiff alleged, in Cronin v. Jamaica Hospital Medical Center, --- N.Y.S.2d ----, 2009 WL 711761 (March 17, 2009), that the defendant wrongfully prolonged the decedent's life by resuscitating him on two occasions against the express instructions of the decedent and his family as contained in two Do-Not-Resuscitate orders issued by the hospital and executed by members of the decedent's family. The Appellate Division, Second Department, affirmed the granting of summary judgment in favor of the defendant and dismissing the complaint on the ground that the plaintiff was asserting a claim for wrongful living and that no such cause of action can be maintained. The status of being alive does not constitute an injury in New York, said the Court. The decision indicates, however, that had the plaintiff submitted evidence raising a triable issue of fact as to whether the decedent was injured as a result of the resuscitations themselves, summary judgment could have been avoided. New Yorks Court of Appeals has held that New York does not recognize a cause of action for wrongful life. Alquijay v. St. Luke's-Roosevelt Hosp. Ctr., 63 N.Y.2d 978; Becker v. Schwartz, 46 N.Y.2d 401, 412. These cases involved claims that a pregnancy would not have occurred or would have been terminated in the absence of medical malpractice. In Alquijay, the baby was born with Downs syndrome that was allegedly not detected by amniocentesis. In Becker, the baby was born with polycystic kidney disease after physicians had advised that the disease, already being suffered by the parents first child, is not hereditary. Interestingly, the Court of Appeals, while not permitting the child to sue for wrongful life, would permit the parents of the child to recover for the extra obligations they would incur (until the infant reached majority) from the birth of the unhealthy child.

Related to This

Levine & Slavit, PLLC Logo

Levine & Slavit, PLLC

The law firm of Levine & Slavit, PLLC has served clients in Long Island and the Greater New York City-area since 1957. We are a team of personal injury and wrongful death lawyers who work tirelessly for victims' rights. Our team is licensed and affiliated with the:

  • New York State Bar Association
  • New Jersey Board of Bar Examiners
  • Florida Board of Bar Examiners
  • U.S. District Court Eastern District of New York
  • U.S. District Court Southern District of New York

Please contact our practice online for a free consultation or call (212) 687-2777 to speak to an attorney today. 

Contact Us Today

Rate, Review & Explore

Social Accounts Sprite
Google map image of our location in 60 E 42nd St Ste 2101 New York, NY

Manhattan Office

60 E 42nd St
Ste 2101
New York, NY 10165

Open Today 8:30am - 5:00pm

By Appointment Only

Google map image of our location in 350 Willis Ave Ste 100 Long Island, NY

Mineola Office

350 Willis Ave
Ste 100
Long Island, NY 11501

Open Today 9:00am - 5:00pm

By Appointment Only

(212) 687-2777 Send a message